Carrie Underwood Posts BTS Footage from ‘American Idol’ Set Fans Have Thoughts

The country superstar dropped a playful Instagram video that left fans both curious and divided.

On March 23, Carrie Underwood sparked conversation by sharing a behind-the-scenes clip from the set of American Idol. Returning as a guest judge for the show’s 23rd season, the singer teased a fun surprise for viewers—but the post quickly took on a life of its own.

A follower comment on Carrie Underwood post from March 23, 2025 | Source: Instagram/carrieunderwood

In the video, Underwood jokingly dragged a key across a car while singing her hit song “Before He Cheats.” She captioned the clip, “Ladies, don’t do this. You’ll ruin your car key! 😂 #CUonIDOL.”

She wrapped the post with a teaser, telling fans to “tune in to find out what happens.” Earlier that day, she’d shared a cheeky photo captioned, “Better not cheat on @americanidol tonight! #CUonIDOL.”

While the video was clearly intended to promote her return to the show, many fans became more focused on something else entirely—Carrie’s appearance.

Carrie Underwood in her video post uploaded on March 23, 2025 | Source: Instagram/carrieunderwood

One follower commented, “Anyone else feel like she’s unrecognizable??” while another added, “She looks different.” A third asked, “Is that a scar under her nose? What happened?”

Source: Instagram/carrieunderwood

More blunt comments followed, like, “Ummm, who is this?? I don’t recognize her at all,” and “You don’t look the same—too much plastic surgery.”

Carrie Underwood in her video post uploaded on March 23, 2025 | Source: Instagram/carrieunderwood

Others reflected on her transformation with posts such as, “From one of the most naturally beautiful to looking like every other celebrity,” and “I see the scar now.”

Despite the split opinions, Carrie’s teaser succeeded in building excitement for her American Idol appearance. Whether it’s a fun promo or fan speculation, Underwood continues to captivate attention—just as she always has.