John Foster’s Version of ‘Guitars, Cadillacs’ Is So Good, You Might Forget the Original—Just for a Moment

John Foster, alongside a fellow rising star, has breathed new life into the country classic “Guitars, Cadillacs,” delivering a performance so captivating it momentarily makes you forget the original. Their undeniable chemistry and stage presence create a rendition that feels both timeless and brand new.

The arrangement is bold and modern, blending classic country sounds with a contemporary, upbeat twist that grabs the audience from the very first guitar strum. Foster’s confident vocal delivery, paired with the rich harmony of his partner, turns this well-known track into something playful, soulful, and entirely unique.

“This isn’t just a cover—it’s a complete reinvention,” one fan commented online. “It’s like hearing the song for the first time, but with today’s heartbeat.”

The performance highlights Foster’s natural charisma and vocal growth throughout American Idol Season 23. As he taps into the emotional roots of country music, Foster also shows he’s not afraid to take risks and make bold artistic choices.

A Moment That Had Everyone Watching—And Feeling

As the song builds, the beat becomes infectious. The audience is pulled in, swaying and smiling, tapping their feet to every note. The duo’s fresh take on Guitars, Cadillacs turns a country classic into a joyful celebration of what modern country music can be—respectful of the past but ready for the future.

“They didn’t just perform the song—they owned it,” said one Idol viewer on social media.

Their version stands out not just for the vocals, but for the soul they bring to the stage. It’s that kind of performance that gets replayed—and remembered.

@qtmandyyy

Another one with Mr. Todd O’Neill. John Foster and Todd O’Neill band! Such an amazing night! #cincodemayo #fypシ゚viral #alwaysagoodtime #johnfostermusic @John Foster

♬ original sound – Amanda

A Love Song, A Look, and a Moment on Stage

On the same night, John Foster also melted hearts with his rendition of “I Cross My Heart” by George Strait during the Judges Song Contest. With his girlfriend Brooklyn Bourque in the audience, the performance took on an even deeper emotional tone.

“You’ll never find a love as true as mine,” Foster sang, locking eyes with Brooklyn as the camera captured her tearful, joy-filled reaction.

Carrie Underwood called his version “absolutely perfect,” and correctly identified as the judge who chose the song for him. Luke Bryan added, “You are singing better and better every week,” praising Foster’s artistic growth and dedication to his craft.

From Underdog to Fan Favorite

John Foster has emerged as one of the most consistent and beloved performers on American Idol 2025. He easily advanced to the Top 7, while the judges saved Mattie Pruitt and sent Josh King home.

Foster’s recent performances have gone viral on social media, with many fans predicting he’ll be in the finale showdown alongside fellow powerhouse Jamal Roberts, who delivered an emotional take on Fantasia’s I Believe.

As American Idol heads into its final weeks—with Disney Nights coming up and intense eliminations looming—John Foster continues to shine as a true country storyteller, honoring tradition while pushing boundaries.