Fans Crown Their Favorites: John Foster, Jamal Roberts, and Breanna Nix Lead Social Media’s Top 3 Ahead of the American Idol Finale

Who will make it to the American Idol 2025 finale? Here’s how fans rank the Top 7 based on their performances and social media buzz!

As American Idol 2025 heads into its most magical phase yet — Disney Night — the pressure is on for the remaining seven contestants. The Top 7 episodes air live coast-to-coast on Sunday, May 11 and Monday, May 12, featuring beloved Disney classics. Each artist will perform twice, with Lin-Manuel Miranda mentoring and Season 21 winner Iam Tongi returning for a special performance of “Hawaiian Roller Coaster Ride” from the new Lilo & Stitch film.

By the end of Monday’s episode, the Top 3 finalists heading to the May 18 finale will be revealed!

American Idol 2025: Top 7 Power Rankings

We’ve analyzed past performances, voting results, and Facebook view counts to determine which contestants are resonating with fans the most. Here’s how they stack up:

1. John Foster

John remains the undeniable front-runner, crushing Facebook views and charming audiences with every performance. His Disney pick, “Almost There” from The Princess and the Frog, may not be his most powerful moment—but his fanbase ensures he’s almost certainly heading to the finale.

Facebook Views (Top 7): 2M
Notable Performance: “I Cross My Heart” by George Strait

2. Jamal Roberts

Jamal is a true triple threat. With strong vocals, emotional depth, and stage presence, his performance of “I Can Go the Distance” from Hercules could be the breakout moment of the season.

Facebook Views (Top 7): 1.1M
Notable Performance: “I Believe” by Fantasia

3. Breanna Nix

Breanna is climbing the ranks quickly. Her Disney Night song, “Reflection” from Mulan, could be the showstopper she needs to cement her Top 3 status.

Facebook Views (Top 7): 605K
Notable Performance: “Independence Day” by Martina McBride

4. Gabby Samone

A consistent powerhouse all season, Gabby’s take on “How Far I’ll Go” will likely shine. A shocking elimination here would stun viewers.

Facebook Views (Top 7): 381K

5. Slater Nalley

Slater’s song choice, “Can You Feel the Love Tonight”, is bold. While he struggles with consistency, his distinct style still connects with fans.

Facebook Views (Top 7): 306K

6. Thunderstorm Artis

Despite low viewership, Thunderstorm’s unique interpretations keep him in the game. His version of “Colors of the Wind” may be a turning point—or the end of the road.

Facebook Views (Top 7): 251K

7. Mattie Pruitt

Mattie’s last-minute save puts her in a vulnerable spot. Her emotional pick, “Remember Me” from Coco, might be her chance to surprise everyone.

Facebook Views (Top 7): 361K

Facebook Engagement: The Secret Predictor?

Fan engagement often foreshadows results, and John Foster is dominating, nearly doubling the views of his closest competitors. Historically, contestants with the lowest views — like Josh King and Thunderstorm Artis — have ended up in the bottom.

Top View Counts from May 5 & 4 Episodes:

• John Foster: 2M / 1.1M
• Jamal Roberts: 1.1M / 677K
• Breanna Nix: 605K / 561K
• Gabby Samone: 381K / 203K
• Mattie Pruitt: 361K / 252K
• Slater Nalley: 306K / 318K
• Thunderstorm Artis: 251K / 396K
• Josh King: (Eliminated) 165K

Conclusion: Who’s Headed to the Finale?

If the numbers and momentum hold, the Top 3 could very well be John Foster, Jamal Roberts, and Breanna Nix. But surprises are common on American Idol, and with Disney songs coming up, anything is possible.

Don’t miss the next episodes of American Idol 2025, airing live Sunday and Monday at 8|7c on ABC — and streaming the next day on Hulu.