John Foster Delivers ‘She Used to Be Mine’ with Quiet, Heartfelt Honesty That Stays with You.

From the very first lines, John Foster’s voice immediately captivates, drawing listeners into the raw emotion of the song. Without overstating anything, he allows the lyrics to carry the feeling—gentle yet deeply moving.

John Foster: American Idol 2025 Top 10 Elimination Info

His voice carries a subtle rasp, reminiscent of classic country, with each note unfolding like a quiet confession. There’s something both heartbreaking and tender in the way he delivers every line.

When the first chorus arrives, his voice rises with controlled power—not showy, but enough to stir the soul. The emotion feels bottled up, now finally released through song.

His expression remains subdued, but his vocal delivery speaks volumes. Every pause, every breath, is carefully placed to deepen the emotion without the need for any additional theatrics.

Halfway through the song, when the lyrics turn to pain and regret, his voice quivers just slightly—as if he’s holding back tears while still striving to finish the story.

No added effects are needed; it’s his honest tone that draws listeners in. The sincerity of his delivery allows the audience to connect deeply with the words he sings.

Each key change or soft modulation is handled with care, not to show off his technical skill, but to gently guide the emotional arc. There’s an undeniable sense of lived experience behind each note—as if this song is a personal story being shared.

@qtmandyyy

No worries…its just @officialjohnfoster singing @Thenashvillepalace with James Carothers and fiddle player, Andy Varner. #johnfoster #johnfostermusic #musicbyjohnfoster #thenashvillepalace #fyppppppppppppppppppppppp #nashville #musiccity #wedontownrightstothismusic #rawvideo #raw #brooksanddunn @Ronnie Dunn

♬ original sound – Amanda

The climax doesn’t thunder—it swells quietly like an emotional tide. In these moments, his voice feels almost like a prayer—soft but profound, hoping to be heard and understood.

By the final line, he lowers his voice to a near whisper. There’s no showmanship—just a haunting, lingering ending, as if the song’s echo remains in the room.

The conclusion doesn’t feel like an end, but more of a pause that lingers in the mind. John Foster’s voice leaves an impact not through grandeur, but through its raw sincerity—and that’s what makes this cover so remarkable.

John Foster honored Carrie Underwood with his rendition of “I Told You So,” the duet she recorded with Randy Travis. John acknowledged Underwood’s unwavering support and wanted to show his gratitude with this performance.

This was John’s first performance without his guitar, yet he still delivered with grace. “I’m blushing!” Underwood exclaimed. “I love that you push yourself with each challenge, trying different songs and styles. It’s been so rewarding to watch you grow every time you take the stage. I’ll speak for Randy Travis here—I truly believe he’d approve.”

Who made the top 10? After the votes were tallied, the top 10 was revealed. The artists moving on to next week (in no particular order) are: John Foster, Josh King, Jamal Roberts, Mattie Pruitt, Thunderstorm Artis, Slater Nalley, Gabby Samone, Canaan James Hill, Kolbi Jordan, and Breanna Nix.

Who was eliminated? Unfortunately, two singers with the lowest votes were eliminated: Che and Filo, who will be going home. The top 10 will perform again on Sunday, May 4.