American Idol Fans Furious: Josh’s Elimination Sparks Outrage as Mattie Snags Last Spot in Top 7

American Idol Season 23 took a dramatic turn during the May 5, 2025 episode, as the Top 8 contestants competed in the highly anticipated Judges’ Song Contest. This unique round saw each judge selecting a song for every contestant, tailored to their vocal style and artistry. However, the ultimate decision was left in the hands of the contestants themselves.

After an evening of emotional performances and intense vocal showdowns, six contestants earned their place directly in the Top 7 through America’s votes:

Slater Nalley
Thunderstorm Artis
Gabby Samone
Breanna Nix
Jamal Roberts
John Foster

This left Mattie Pruitt and Josh King in the bottom two — with only one contestant having the chance to stay in the competition.

Judges’ Save: Mattie Pruitt Chosen, Fans React

Because of a tie in the Judges’ Song Contest, Luke Bryan and Lionel Richie were given the power to save one of the bottom two contestants. After conferring, they chose to save Mattie, sending Josh home, despite Carrie Underwood’s input being left out of the decision-making process.

Social Media Reactions:

• Support for Josh:
  “Mattie absolutely didn’t deserve the save on #AmericanIdol tonight. Josh was better and she’s been mediocre the last two weeks.”
  “They picked Mattie? Are they kidding? Josh wasn’t going to win, but he’s way better than her.”
  “I MIGHT have given it to Josh. Not SUPER mad, but still surprised.”

Many fans highlighted Josh’s humility in the face of elimination:
“Josh was literally so sweet for telling them to save Mattie.”

• Support for Mattie:
  “The right choice was made. Josh is a cool guy, but it was definitely his time to go.”
  “Mattie deserved the save — but I think she’s in danger next week.”
  “I wish Josh well, but I think America FINALLY got it right tonight.”

The Controversy and Fan Reactions

The reaction from fans was swift and polarized, with many taking to social media platforms like X (formerly Twitter) to voice their opinions. Some fans supported the decision to save Mattie, while others were furious over Josh’s elimination. Regardless of the divisive nature of the judges’ choice, it sparked a much-needed conversation about the competition’s integrity and the power of fan votes.

American Idol Season 23 Top 7 Finalists

After the dust settled, host Ryan Seacrest revealed the official Top 7 contestants advancing to the next round, which will include a Disney-themed Mother’s Day week:

• Slater Nalley
• Thunderstorm Artis
• Gabby Samone
• Breanna Nix
• Jamal Roberts
• John Foster
• Mattie Pruitt (Judges’ Save)

Eliminated: Josh King

What’s Next for American Idol Fans?

The competition continues on Sunday, May 11, with a Disney Night + Mother’s Day celebration. The Top 7 contestants will perform Disney classics and pay tribute to their moms in an emotional two-night special.

On May 12, Broadway legend Lin-Manuel Miranda will mentor the finalists as America votes for the Top 5. The stage will be set for the May 18 finale, where the Top 3 will battle for the win.

Don’t miss out on this exciting season! Tune in to American Idol on Sundays and Mondays at 8/7c on ABC.